Saturday, February 21, 2009

10 Beliefs of This Progressive Christian

Ok, there is so much in that title that makes me nervous.  Despite working at a Progressive Christian church, I usually resist at all costs calling myself a Christian (just too confusing a term to try to explain). I also resist talking about my religion in terms of what I believe, because I find my beliefs are ever-changing and belief tends to imply dogma, which I just don’t do.

That being said this should be fun :)

Here goes… Ten Beliefs of This Progressive Christian 

1) I believe that interfaith dialogue is essential to understanding the world and to know Truths my tradition has missed or omitted.

2) I believe stories found in the Bible, when understood as metaphor and myth, can be used to teach me profound Truths.

3) I believe there are as many ways to be Christian as there are people in the tradition.

4) I believe the way I understand Jesus, as a radical activist and a compassionate teacher, shows more about my way of viewing the world than it does any “truth” of Jesus. The truth is he lived a long time ago and the records are not clear.

5) I believe religion should lead you to more questions than answers.

6) I believe my tradition causes me to question social values of the day and to push society to be more inclusive.  That being the case, I believe Christianity should be on the forefront of fighting for the human rights of people who are gay, lesbian, and transgendered. 

7) I believe religion is only one piece of the pie and should not be confused with history, science, psychology, or other important disciplines.  All are needed for a balanced life.

8) I believe much hatred has been caused by the interpretation of Christianity by some throughout history and today; leading to wars, bigotry, racism, sexism, homophobia, etc. This one belief alone has caused me to turn my back on Christianity many times, and constantly question why I am connected at all. 

9) I believe the following of a religious or spiritual tradition with the support of a community can lead to great transformation of individuals and cultures. This one belief alone has caused me to stay within Christianity hoping to be a part of this transformation of consciousness, the next great awakening.

10) I believe no one knows what happens after this life, and if we spent even half as much time bringing the peace to this world that so many hope for in the next, we could experience heaven on earth.

12 comments:

John Shuck said...

Wow! These are great beliefs. I found myself resonating with all of them. Thanks!

Anonymous said...

Christianity and Christian beliefs have remained the same. It is people that want to change the tradition of Christianity that are wrong.

Unknown said...

Allison, your thoughts are wonderful. I did not suspect that you were such a clear and profound thinker. Keep up the good work.

Hannah said...

I really like 9 and 10...you have a great way of articulating very important "truths" about Christianity. Thanks for sharing this!

Allison said...

Thanks for the comments! Really all of them are great and much appreciated. I love that we got some diverse opinions here.

To address the anonymous comment- through my study of the history of Christianity in college (which was 1/4 of my religion major), I learned that the Christian tradition has changed greatly over the years, which prompted the writing of many creeds and created many different denominations.

Maybe the question we are dealing with here is who has the power to change Christianity. Is it only in the hands of the Pope or church leaders?

Anonymous said...

Beautiful!
Beautiful!
Beautiful!

Anonymous said...

You might like the book I'm reading called *The Closing of the Western Mind: the Rise of Faith and the Fall of Reason* by Charles Freeman. I wish he had given more attention to the determination of the canon of the New Testament, but his history of the creeds and the definition of orthodoxy is fascinating, touching on many of the points you make. http://www.amazon.com/Closing-Western-Mind-Faith-Reason/dp/1400033802/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1235423920&sr=1-1

Anonymous said...

I think the only thing all "Christians" have in common is that they call themselves Christian. Notice too your reference in no. 1 to "my tradition".

I am also convinced there are an infinite number of ways to express onesself as a "progressive Christian". Regardless of how you choose to express it, however, the value in hanging on to the term is... Read More keeping bigots from owning the term for themselves alone. Christian history is full of progressives. St. Francis, Dorothy Day, Martin Luther King... Don't worry if it didn't mean the same thing to all of them.

Allison said...

Thanks for the great comments, insights, and book suggestions everyone, this is so great!

I wanted to share an email with you I received this week in response to this blog. (I omitted the name to protect the privacy).

Allison,

A friend sent me your Beliefs about Progressive Christianity just after I had tearfully confessed to her that I no longer belong in our church because I can't say that I believe in God. Being a student of Spong, Borg and now 3C, I feel extremely hypocritical with my fellow church members. Anyway, your writing help relieve my feelings of hypocrisy, because I strongly believe in the way of Jesus...as teacher...as social redeemer.

Thank you,
A Bible Belt resident with no place to go

Anonymous said...

I heartily agree. Beautifully said.

Anonymous said...

Allison...
I occasionally check-in on your blog because I'm fascinated by someone with such complete opposite views as myself.

I think point #10 creates the most cognitive dissonance, personally..

If you acknowledge Jesus as some kind of "radical activist and compassionate teacher", than you have to have something to base that statement on. This means you acknowledge (on some level) that some of the Scriptural writings about him are accurate. From those same scriptural writings we see that Jesus was incredibly "heaven-minded". He went great lengths to talk about the kingdom-of-heaven, and it wasn't just a metaphor for a 'more peaceful earth'. He made it clear he didn't come to plant flowers and hug bears. He came to "seek and save the lost".

So, statement #10 is of no comfort to a mother who saw her 6-year-old child die before her eyes, or a 60 year-old murderer who's in jail lives with incredible guilt and fear of what happens when he dies.
"I don't know where you or your loved one is going, but we can make this world a better place" does not help them in their time of need.

Even if I were to acknowledge the possibility that Jesus and the Christian church He established is 'full of it' and made up, it's no more bogus than any other system of belief, including yours. And I, for one, like the comfort and peace that comes in knowing where I'm going, instead of embracing a "spirituality" with no anchor and little substance.

(I admit, though, - regretfully - that people have been hurt/killed in the name of Christ, and that is just shameful.)

Allison said...

Josh-

Thank you so much for your post! I loved that you started by saying you read this blog because my beliefs are the opposite of yours. That is awesome! So often we only seek out opinions of people who think like us (I can be guilty of this). I really appreciate your openness.

The point that I was trying to make in statement #10 is that sometimes religious beliefs in the afterlife, in my opinion, cause us to look to an uncertain future (no one actually knows what happens after we die) rather than focusing on the present moment.

I hear your point about seeking comfort for those grieving or those with regrets. Ironically, stories as they are often told in the Christian tradition of an afterlife of heaven for some and hell for others do not bring me comfort.

In my job, I have had the incredible opportunity of being with people when they have lost a loved one, and have lost people I have cared for deeply in our community. My approach is to be present to the pain of the moment. To just sit with people in that time. It is awful and physically hurts, and I believe is an important part of the human experience. Both the mortality of our loved ones and awakening to our own mortality is one of the most profound teachers we encounter.

I would never say to someone i don't know where your loved one is going, but let's go fix the world. That is very callous response. I also would never feel comfort offering a false comfort to avoid the depth of feeling of the situation.

Thanks again Josh for your honest thoughts!
Allison